Culham Research Group
Just another blogs.reading.ac.uk site
Skip to content
  • Home
  • About
  • Advent Botany
    • Advent Botany 2014
    • Advent Botany 2015
    • Advent Botany 2016
    • Advent Botany 2017
    • Advent Botany 2019
    • Taxonomic index to #AdventBotany
  • PhD Students
    • Ahmed Gawhari – PhD 2016
    • Ana Simoes
    • Anas Tawfeeq
    • Azi Jamaludin
    • Donald Zulu
    • Jordan Bilsborrow
    • Maria Christodoulou – PhD 2016
    • Tomos Jones
    • Widad Aljuhani – PhD 2015
    • Kálmán Könyves – PhD 2014
    • Marshall Heap – PhD 2014
    • Ahmed El-Banhawy
    • Hassan Rankou
    • Oli Ellingham
    • Aramide Dolapo Oshingboye – L’Oreal Visiting Fellowship 2014/2015
  • Projects
← #AdventBotany Day 6: Fantastic Mastic
#AdventBotany Day 8: Cultivating Christmas →

#AdventBotany Day 7: ‘like a Shoshana among the thorns’

Posted on December 7, 2017 by Alastair Culham

By Robert Blackhall-Miles FLS

Last year for advent botany I wrote about the Madonna lily (Lilium candidum) and its links to the Christmas story and the song of Solomon. This year, however, I propose another hypothesis as to the identity of the ‘Lily of the valley’ and the ‘Rose of Sharon’.
Another set of leaves makes its presence felt on my research nursery at this time of year. Curled and grey-green in colour they stand out vividly against the sand in their ‘long tom’ pots. From the moment they emerge they become a niggling worry. There is no easy hope here. They are a struggle and a torment, and my hope is only that I may keep them alive. If they reward me with flowers for my efforts, then I am jubilant. If they die I am afraid I am disappointed but never surprised. The aphids love them; spreading virus if I am not eagle eyed. When dormant and dry they are safe: yet If I water them too early to bring them into growth they rot, too late and they wither. They are my passion and have been my nemesis.
I have been told many times that I won’t be able to grow them successfully here in North Wales yet I carry on. They are a goal that I strive for and am pleased to say, tentatively, achieving.

Iris atropurpurea ‘Ben Ram’

I am talking of the Iris in the section Oncocyclus.
There are 8 species of Oncocyclus (some authorities suggest there are actually 9 or more) in Israel yet the section is found over a broad area of the middle east and Eastern Mediterranean. Growing from a rounded rhizome (Onco meaning mass and Cyclus meaning circular) they are found from Turkey and Georgia in the north through Iran and Iraq in the east and as far down as Egypt in the south-western edge of their range. Their flowers come in the same range of jewel colours as the wrappers of a box of chocolates and nearly all of them brandish a dark spot on their fall indicating an over night rest station for male solitary bees which facilitate their pollination. Scientifically the section is neatly defined, they have 2n = 20 chromosomes where their next nearest relatives in the section Regalia have 2n = 22, yet the species within it are certainly not.

Iris susiana L. in the Linnean Society collection

The type for the section is the Turkish species I. susiana (from ‘Susan’ or ‘Sawsan’) and this then leads to their Hebrew name of ‘Shoshan’ Irises.
‘By incident, if your name happens to be Susan, Susanna, Anne, Ann or Anna then it is derived from this ancient Hebrew name for the lily.’ – or is it an Iris?
The idea that the Lily of the valley, the rose of Sharon was really a lily, as I proposed in last year’s blog, starts to unravel.
The word Sharon itself may be a Synonymous parallelism and actually mean valley. The Madonna lilies are most certainly not ‘of the valley’ but of the mountains and thus we need to look to a different plant for our ‘Lily of the Valley’

The etymology of Shoshanna שושנה states quite clearly that the flower had six petals, where a rose has five, – shishi שִׁשִּׁי (from which Shosh is derived) being the ancient Hebrew for six. These six petals fit snugly with the lily yet they also fit so snugly with the six petals, the standards and falls, of an Iris which is certainly a plant found in valleys.

Iris atropurpurea showing urban encroachment

Iris atropurpurea grows in HaSharon, or the Sharon plane, where it is endangered by coastal development and a genetic bottleneck. It seems to fit even more appropriately when you think of other lines of the song. ‘like a Shoshana among the thorns’, ‘Like two fawns, the doe’s twins, grazing among the shashanim’ and ‘his lips are shoshanim’. The thorns may not be those of a rose or the spines of the Smilax or Ziziphus on the Carmel hill but more probably those of the thistles of the Sharon plane, the Iris grow best in these grazed habitats and only the lips of the dead are white like a lily; most people’s lips are pink like the flowers of this iris.
And that Fleur-de-lis, the emblem of the scouts and so widely depicted on the robes of Mary, is so very closely reminiscent of an iris flower it is almost recognisable as such.
Shoshan is mentioned 15 times during the course of the bible and only twice does it not refer to a flower.
Jesus is referred to as ‘Lily of the valley’ and the ‘Rose of Sharon’ in many songs and Psalms from the Christian faith. Some believe the depiction of love in Solomon’s song was a prediction of the one true love to come – the love of Christ – and the whole reason for our celebration of Christmas.
Alas we cannot turn back time and discover the true meaning of all of this. The Greeks and Romans both had their impacts on the ancient languages of the Middle East and modern Hebrew has taken on these changes. It is certain however that the wildflowers of this tiny strip of the eastern Mediterranean feature heavily in many cultures and not least of all Christianity.
With the Mediterranean basin having such a high level of speciation and being so heavily impacted by the activities of man this flora is in grave danger of becoming myth just as the Shoshana of the bible. Iris atropurpurea is likely to become the first Israeli endemic species to become extinct and 6 of the other 7 species of Iris in Israel are threatened with extinction (Sapir, 2016).

It seems that my passion and my nemesis may just have a deeper story than their chocolate wrapper flowers are able to tell.

Sapir, Y. 2016. Iris atropurpurea. The IUCN Red List of Threatened Species 2016: e.T13161450A18611400. http://dx.doi.org/10.2305

All images courtesy Robert Blackhall-Miles.

Share this:

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn
  • Email
  • Tumblr
  • Pinterest
  • Pocket
  • Print
  • More
  • Reddit
  • Press This
  • Google

Like this:

Like Loading...

About Alastair Culham

A professional botanist and biologist with an interest in promoting biological knowledge and awareness to all.
View all posts by Alastair Culham →
This entry was posted in Advent, Public Engagement with Science and tagged #AdventBotany, Advent, conservation, Iris, IUCN Red List, Robbie Blackhall-Miles. Bookmark the permalink.
← #AdventBotany Day 6: Fantastic Mastic
#AdventBotany Day 8: Cultivating Christmas →
Logging In...

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

  • 1 Reply
  • 0 Comments
  • 0 Tweets
  • 0 Facebook
  • 1 Pingback
Last reply was December 7, 2017
  1. #AdventBotany Day7: ‘like a Shoshana among the thorns’ – by Robert Blackhall-Miles « Herbology Manchester
    View December 7, 2017

    […] via #AdventBotany Day 7: ‘like a Shoshana among the thorns’ — Culham Research Group […]

    Reply
  • Recent Posts

    • #AdventBotany 2019 Day 6: Deck the Halls with Boughs of Holly…
    • Final call: help identify potentially invasive plants
    • #AdventBotany 2019 Day 2: Death by chocolate
    • #AdventBotany 2019, Day 1: Clementine, Satsuma, Tangerine; what’s the difference?
    • Teacher Training
  • Recent Comments

    • #AdventBotany 2019 Day 2: Death by chocolate | Culham Research Group on 2014 Advent Botany – Day 16 – Chocolate (Theobroma cacao)
    • #AdventBotany 2019, Day 1: Clementine, Satsuma, Tangerine; what’s the difference? | Culham Research Group on Advent Botany 2015 – Day 18: The Tangerine – Just Like a Virgin
    • Buraidah Date Festival - Saudi Arabia Tourism Guide on Candy Of the Desert
    • A hunt for some of the UK’s most rarely recorded fungal treasures | Culham Research Group on The Lost and Found Fungi Project – Kew
    • A VLOG to celebrate the 5th birthday of the #AdventBotany blog series | Bazely Biology lab: collaborative, interdisciplinary, fun on 2014 Advent Botany – Day 19 – Parsnip (Pastinaca sativa)
  • Categories

    • Advent
    • Art
    • Catalogue of Life
    • Collectors
    • e-learning
    • Hawkins Research Group
    • Herbarium RNG
    • i4Life
    • MSc Plant Diversity
    • PhD research
    • Public Engagement with Science
    • RHS research
    • Type
    • Uncategorized
    • Welcome
  • Meta

    • Register
    • Log in
    • Entries RSS
    • Comments RSS
    • WordPress.org
    • RSS - Posts
    • RSS - Comments
  • Subscribe to Blog via Email

    Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

  • Privacy & Cookies: This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this website, you agree to their use.
    To find out more, including how to control cookies, see here: Cookie Policy
Culham Research Group
Proudly powered by WordPress.
loading Cancel
Post was not sent - check your email addresses!
Email check failed, please try again
Sorry, your blog cannot share posts by email.
%d bloggers like this: